On the first night of Passover, a night meant to symbolize freedom, redemption, and the safety of home, Governor Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania found himself and his family confronting an unthinkable nightmare. At approximately 2:00 a.m., as the Shapiro family rested after hosting a Passover Seder, state troopers urgently awoke them to inform them that their home had been set ablaze. Molotov cocktails had shattered windows, igniting the dining and piano rooms in an act of shocking violence and brazen political hatred (read Jew Hatred).
Governor Shapiro, the Jewish governor of Pennsylvania, and his family, guests included, were swiftly evacuated and thankfully unharmed. But physical safety is not the same as emotional security, nor does survival erase the chilling implications of what had transpired. The attacker, identified as Cody Balmer, later surrendered himself, citing anger at Governor Shapiro’s position on Israel and Gaza, and referencing his anger at perceived injustices against Palestinians as a motivation for this heinous act.
While shocking, equally unsettling has been the minimal attention and coverage this incident has garnered in national media and public discourse. A violent attack—explicitly political and implicitly antisemitic—targeting a sitting Jewish governor, his family, and their home during Passover should, by any reasonable standard, be cause for widespread alarm and condemnation. Instead, this troubling silence raises profound questions about our collective societal response, our selective outrage, and the subtle ways in which antisemitism and political violence continue to be normalized or ignored.
Let us be clear: political disagreements, even profound ideological divides, are legitimate in a healthy democracy. They are necessary for growth, accountability, and progress. But when political grievances translate into violence—particularly violence explicitly targeting individuals for their identity, faith, or symbolic representation of a group—society must respond unequivocally and collectively. The muted reaction in this instance exposes a troubling double standard: certain acts of hatred and violence garner extensive attention and swift condemnation, while others quietly fade into the backdrop, unnoticed, unaddressed, and consequently unchallenged.
This selective response has deep implications. When acts of hate are ignored or minimized, the message inadvertently communicated is that certain forms of violence are acceptable, or at least not deserving of serious attention. The resulting silence becomes a fertile breeding ground for further radicalization and violence. Moreover, for targeted communities—in this case, the Jewish community—the silence compounds the trauma, reinforcing feelings of isolation, vulnerability, and alienation.
Governor Shapiro’s public response has been marked by dignity, resilience, and determination. “I will not be deterred in my work, and I will not be afraid to do that work,” he affirmed. This defiant stance is crucial and commendable, demonstrating leadership in the face of violence. Yet, it cannot and should not absolve society from its broader responsibility to confront the underlying currents of antisemitism, political extremism, and hatred that have become disturbingly commonplace in our national dialogue.
As Jews, as Americans, and simply as human beings committed to justice and dignity, we must refuse to accept this silence. We must insist on a consistent ethical standard in our public discourse, condemning acts of hate unequivocally, regardless of their target or ideological motivations. We must hold media, political leaders, and our own communities accountable for addressing all forms of hate and violence with equal vigor and moral clarity.
Passover teaches us about the eternal struggle for freedom and dignity, about standing against oppression and violence, and about remembering that our liberation is bound up with that of others. Let the fire at the governor’s residence remind us of the urgency of this struggle. Let it shake us from complacency and move us to action—not just for Josh Shapiro and his family, but for the principles of justice, freedom, and safety that we hold dear.
Silence in the face of hate and violence, wherever and however it appears, is complicity. Our voices, our outrage, our willingness to speak truth, even when uncomfortable, remain our most powerful weapons against darkness.
Leave a Reply