We live in a time when many Jews feel more comfortable repairing the world than repairing themselves. They show up to marches, staff nonprofits, amplify causes. They speak eloquently about social justice, equality, and inclusion. But if asked about Shabbat, tefillah, Hebrew literacy, or the moral demands of Jewish peoplehood, many would fall silent. Not because they don’t care—but because they were never taught that tikkun olam—repairing the world—was once part of something deeper: tikkun atzmenu, the repair of the self.
In modern Jewish discourse, these two ideas have become disjointed. One is outward-facing, moral, global. The other is inward, spiritual, tribal. And in the name of universalism, we’ve over-privileged the first at the expense of the second. We are now a people who can chant slogans of justice in the streets of Brooklyn, but are embarrassed to say the word Zion. We can organize for others, but feel conflicted about organizing for ourselves. We show up for everyone else’s story, but hesitate to tell our own. This is not righteousness. This is spiritual dislocation.
The two terms are often treated as separate, even oppositional: tikkun olam as social justice, tikkun atzmenu as religious piety. But that division is false. In the rabbinic imagination, they are two halves of the same spiritual project. The world cannot be mended unless the self is whole. And the self cannot be whole unless it is committed to the repair of the world. The Talmud in Bava Metzia (107b) teaches: “Begin with yourself, and then extend to others.” In other words: you are not ready to carry others’ pain until you have confronted your own.
The phrase tikkun olam appears not in modern activist liturgy, but in the Aleinu prayer: l’takein olam b’malchut Shaddai—to repair the world under the sovereignty of God. This is not a vague social ideal. It is a vision of universal order anchored in divine particularism—a world transformed through fidelity to Jewish covenant, ritual, and destiny. Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik once warned that a Judaism stripped of particularism, history, and obligation becomes “a vague humanitarianism.” And that is what has happened in many corners of American Jewish life. In our rush to be relevant, we have outsourced our identity to progressive language and abandoned the grammar of Torah. We are fluent in global ethics—and illiterate in our own.
We care more about the stranger than we do about our neighbor. More about racial justice than Jewish continuity. More about the moral posture of the world than the spiritual condition of our own people. None of this stems from bad intentions. It stems from disorientation—what the mystics called galut ha-da’at, exile of the mind. We are so afraid of being parochial, nationalist, exclusionary, that we would rather erase our own story than be accused of privileging it. But that fear has consequences. We are now watching a generation of young Jews who feel alienated from Israel, uncomfortable with Zionism, detached from Jewish practice, and still believe they are living Jewish values. And when the world turns against the Jewish people—as it always does—they are not sure whether to defend it, apologize for it, or stay silent.
In such a moment, we do not need more tikkun olam. We need tikkun atzmenu. A spiritual reset. A moral realignment. Not to withdraw from the world—but to re-enter it with memory and meaning. The Kotzker Rebbe once said: “When I was young, I wanted to change the world. I failed. So I tried to change my city. I failed. Then I tried to change my family. I failed again. So I decided to change myself. And I succeeded. And suddenly, I saw that my family changed, my city changed, and the world changed.” This is not a retreat from responsibility. It is a theology of transformation. Tikkun atzmenu is not navel-gazing. It is the foundation of real, lasting, non-performative repair.
This is also the lesson of Lurianic Kabbalah, where the concept of tikkun originates. Before there is cosmic repair, there is cosmic shattering. Before the light is restored, the vessels must be rebuilt. And the vessels are us. As the Zohar teaches: “A person who purifies themselves, purifies the whole world” (Zohar I:219a).
For tikkun olam and tikkun atzmenu to live in balance, the world must become a place that allows particularism to be seen as sacred, not selfish. It must affirm that the repair of the self is a form of ethical preparation, not moral cowardice. In that world, Jewish identity would be a source of moral power, not a liability. A Jew could wear a kippah to a protest, not just a rainbow pin. Torah study would be understood not as retreat, but as preparation for ethical action. Love for Am Yisrael would not have to be disavowed to show compassion for others. Rabbi Jonathan Sacks wrote: “The only people who can truly care for the dignity of others are those who are not afraid to assert their own.”
If we do not return to tikkun atzmenu, we will eventually lose the capacity to perform tikkun olam with integrity. Because a people without memory cannot offer meaning. A people who are embarrassed by their story cannot carry anyone else’s. And a people who outsource their moral compass to whatever the secular left (or right) deems acceptable will find themselves always chasing approval—and never building anything lasting.
Over time, we risk becoming a community of beautiful causes and hollow souls. We will speak the language of justice while forgetting the poetry of Am Yisrael. We will fund other people’s freedom movements while apologizing for our own. We will produce generations who are kind, generous, and deeply lost. Eventually, tikkun olam will stop working—not because it’s wrong, but because we will have no “we” left to do the repairing. There is a name for this in Jewish history: disintegration. And it never ends well.
To bring tikkun atzmenu and tikkun olam into harmony, we need to undertake three forms of spiritual realignment. First, we must reclaim Jewish learning. Tikkun atzmenu begins with literacy—without Torah, we are left with feelings and borrowed slogans. Jewish values cannot be sustained by vibes and hashtags. They require language, texts, memory, and law. Second, we must rebuild Jewish community—not as a social club, but as a spiritual engine. We need communal spaces that are alive with prayer, study, and obligation. Minyan, mikvah, mitzvah. Not performative inclusivity, but rooted Jewish continuity. Third, we must reassert Jewish peoplehood—not as a nationalist identity, but as a sacred family. We do not need to apologize for loving our own. In fact, it is only from that love that we can love others without self-erasure.
We need a Jewish ethic that can say: yes to prison reform—and yes to Shacharit. Yes to racial justice—and yes to Hebrew school. Yes to LGBTQ dignity—and yes to aliyah to Israel. Yes to global empathy—but not at the expense of Jewish continuity. These are not contradictions. They are the architecture of a Judaism that is both rooted and relevant—grounded in covenant and awake to the world.
When we hold tikkun atzmenu and tikkun olam together, we stop pretending that the only question worth asking is whether we are progressive enough. Because in too many corners of Jewish life, progressive has become the currency of belonging, and Jewish is an afterthought—assumed, ornamental, or optional. But tikkun demands more. It demands that we be both rooted and responsive. It asks not only what we stand for, but where we stand from. When we restore that balance, we stop performing virtue for the world and begin embodying responsibility to it. We stop chasing borrowed ethics, and begin living our own. Only then will our justice work be coherent. Only then will our spiritual lives bear fruit. Only then will we be able to offer the world something it cannot generate on its own: a people who remember who they are.
“Prepare yourself in the hallway so you may enter the palace,” teaches Pirkei Avot. The hallway is tikkun atzmenu. The palace is tikkun olam. The world does not need Jews who erase themselves in the name of others. It needs Jews who have the courage to be whole—so they can help the world become so, too.
Leave a Reply